norgepoolie wrote:
MFR wrote:
I think the whole arguement comes down to your feelings towards the state. I would willingly pay more taxes to the state to assist public spending, because thats how I think democracy works - those who have help out those who have not. Yup, there will be those that take the pi$$, but thats life. Doesnt mean you stop the basis of an excellent welfare system because some think that too many are at it. Benefit fraud, whilst large and needing addressing, pales into insignificance when compared to large scale corporate and individual tax avoidance.
I would vote for any party that advocated raising taxes to improve the society in which we all live - better healthcare, better infrastructure etc.
I would vote for any party that advocated spending the same resources challanging and prosecuting tax avoidance as it does benefit fraud.
Our Tory, and now Liberal, brethern would rather the state buggered off and it was left to individuals to sort out their own $hit with the minimal of state interference. Its just a difference of opinion and ideology and its a shame that the present governemnt want to claim that deficit reduction is crucial to our economic welfare.
It isnt, indeed there is a real arguement that increased public spending would aid the economy and generate growth. The cuts are mainly ideology based, and there can be little arguement with them as they were voted in in a democratic mandate. I only hope I am around long enough for the cyclical nature of politcs to return the current ideology to the anals of history and that society hasnt been twisted and bent beyond repair by that time.
The sentiment is admirable. Unfortunately the reality is different. In an ideal world what you say would be fine but we have watched our personal freedoms being slowly eroded for the last 13 years. The state should look after the old, the young, the poor, the sick and the unemployed, especially those who want to work. That is a given. That is what the majority of Labour voters want. What we got was increased surveillance of ordinary people (check out the stats), snooping councils putting microchips in bins, jobs for the boys in useless quangos, illegal wars, cash for honours, the sheer hypocrisy of attacking benefit cheats whilst all the time milking the system for all it's worth (all parties guilty), Public Sector Executives being paid superstar salaries to suppposedly compete with the private sector, the "blind eye" turned to the banks and big business, the un-checked immigration, ID cards, CCTV which catches people dropping litter but fails miserably with any real crime, ridiculous health & safety rules, the end of automatic trial by jury, the end of the right to remain silent, the police using anti-terror laws to stop and search ordinary people..... The list is endless. Are the new lot any better? I've no idea, but they can't be any worse and this is from an ex Labour voter.
No arguments at all there Norge, at no point would I offer up New Labour as a beacon of light. They behaved in some ways admirably, ie increased NHS spending, but otherwise behaved in the manner in which you kinda thought they would ie Tory Lite. CCTV, ID cards and a general continued toddieing (?) to the City are all bollox to name a few.
The point I was trying to make is that this new government will behave in an manner driven by an ideology that is, IMO, not good for a growth in decent society. Slashing public spending will appease Daily Mail readers and their kin but will it really benefit us all in the long run? If deficit reduction is really the main thrust, increase personal taxation and nail tax avoidance over say a 3 or 5 year programme - that will really help. Our National Debt whilst huge is mainly long term debt and for the most bond-derived. This type of debt is the most serviceable and thereby manageable - its huge but hey ho we are a big bleedin country! Closing a hospital here and there, not loaning ForgeMasters money will make good headlines and punish the North, but that's about it.
My main gripe would be Clegg - W.T.F. is he doing? He heads a party that had some principles that he has just sold for a sniff of power. That's them doomed into the elective desert for years to come and I am genuinely surprised he took them there.
I aspire to assist ;)