ElvisAintDead wrote:
I don't think people at The Club are "dismissive" of The Bunker.
I reckon they think that certain posters are simply on a massive wind-up and would find two negatives on a car battery, but that's MY opinion as well so I know where they're coming from.
I would say that The Club have picked up a few IDEAS from here, rather than dismissed it...
How about this. Lets say The Club set up a Fans Forum where The Bunker was allowed three representatives on a regular "Panel" to toss ideas about and forge better links with The Club?
Which three Bunker Regulars do you reckon The Club would take seriously after recent events on here?
Serious Question.
Fire Away...
First of all, would you say that a "fans forum" is a possibility EAD ???? I'm presuming it's a hypothetical question, but let's say it's not for the time being
I actually mentioned something along the lines of a fans forum to a mate the other day in response to the club asking fans for their ideas, that once the ideas had been received by the club, a meeting was arranged with a number of fans and they were all discussed prior to any (if thought good) being put into practice by the club.
Now although I thought it was a good idea , the person I discussed it with disagreed. His point of view was how would the "fans" selected to discuss the ideas with club officials be selected. Now he's not a user of the bunker but does very occasionally hear what has been posted on here. His first reply was that any one who had posted criticism "allegedly" would almost certainly be ruled out by the club. (now they not my words), resulting in a "panel" of what he called "yes" men.
He pointed out that maybe someone from the supporter's association and HUDSA could be on it, but that might look once more like it being a "closed shop" with regards to which group of fans were invited on to it. Would the fans be from each section of the home end's of the ground. If not then how would they know what affects each area.
Now let's take the only viable suggestion made when I started this reply
Mick Tait's Head Bandage wrote:
I'd go for your good self, Mad John and Chip
.
I could agree with that selection, but putting a devils advocate head on, the selection of yourself may not go down well in some quarter's on here,or with fans as a whole you already have a close working relationship with the club which some may feel creates a conflict of interest.
If it's a viable idea and it being looked into, then I believe something like 5 fans need to brought in.
One from each side of ground, one from HUDSA and one from the supporters association.
Now the one's from HUDSA and the supporters group can be selected easily enough from their respective associations. The problem you have is to try and get someone from all sides of the home end's who joins the forum but joins with a "neutral head", willing to listen to all other points of view including the clubs and simply not go to the meeting with pre conceived ideas, and only having his/her agenda on how things should be done.
If the club can do that, and the people who are "elected"/ "chosen" to be part of it then I believe it will help , so if it as I asked at the start a possibility I say go for it, and if it's 3 people off here the club wants then simply ask for nominations with someone proposing people and try to find a way of getting the 3 BEST people for the job. Though not an vote on here, open to being "fixed" as people go from computer to computer voting for whoever and 100's of new user names being created to do the same.