derwent wrote:
Aren't Man City trying to emulate the others though? It seems to me that they are no different from the four they are trying to join in with.
Derwent, I would say they are similar to Chelsea but not the other three. Liverpool, Manu and Arsenal have a much grubbier history going back to the scrapping of the attendance pot and gate sharing; they were all also part of the original "Big Five" who started all the "give us the TV money or we break away" talks way back in the 1980s, and were big players in the eventual breakaway a few years later. And not content with getting their own way against a pitifully weak/complicit FA back then, they then set about carving up Europe, getting extra guaranteed matches (and money) via the Champions League (wasn't the European Cup fantastic?!). By doing so they created this league where the top few get richer and pull away from the rest. They are anti-competition and anti-football.
The only way to get into that elite company these days is by financial might. Chelsea did so, and City will look to follow them. City, like Chelsea and others, do have some blood on their hands. They broke away from the Football League with the rest, and must take some blame for the financial chasm between the Prem and the FL. So it's a shame that it's City who are trying to crash the party. Someone like Hull would have been better.
City have their own anti-competitive skeletons. Way back in the 1930s there was nearly a third Manchester club in the League. Manchester Central FC had been accepted by the Division Three (North) only to find their admission vetoed by City and United, who didn't want the competition. The League rolled over and sided with the big boys.
Thanks for that very comprehensive and interesting answer.
As far as I'm concerned they are all the same.
There were the instigators as you have pointed out but the rest have followed/ are following like sheep. Every single one of them would like a massive stadium, massive support, big financial clout etc etc.
That is why I lump them all together. Where someone leads the sheep will follow.