MadJohn wrote:
I wouldn't say Broad is particularly over-rated. Most cricket fans, while acknowledging his potential, recognise that he has a lot of work to do before the can be secure as a Test cricketer.
As for Flintoff, he's one of those cases where the stats don't tell the whole story. There was discussion a couple of weeks before the first Test when Flintoff's fitness wasn't certain. Ryan Sidebottom's name cropped up. Now whichever way you choose to measure it (wkts per innings, 5 wt hauls, average, strike rate, economy) Sidebottom is a superior Test bowler to Flintoff. Except... he isn't. Australia would be delighted if Flintoff was unavailable and replaced by any other English bowler.
The thing about broad as well he can bat