Kolley Kibber wrote:
Maybe a small minority of teachers tell the pupils to use Wikipedia as a way of gathering information, but I can tell you the majority will not. There is a drive on at the moment to push pupils to select relevant information from the internet to use in their work, and pupils must be able to understand that Wikipedia is seen as unreliable. I certainly wouldn't use it in my class - Spartacus Schools is far, far better for anything historical and serves the same purpose.
I do laugh at people who slag the education system off, the same people who don't have a f*** clue about how schools are ran today and what is going on in the background. Jesus Christ, history teaching 30 years ago consisted of a teacher standing at the class and saying 'here are 10 facts, write them down'. What use is that to anybody? More factual knowledge? So what? Pupils today are taught loads of transferable skills from a young age; how to analyse, evaluate, judge, compare and interpret. These type of skills are the ones that are valued in the real world. The education system is not perfect, far from it, but to say it is regressing is a total crock of shiit.
I think the 'now' v 'then' arguments about education are a bit futile. Some things were better then, other things are better now. Also, different people learn in different ways, so it's all difficult to assess.
I do think 'facts' are important, and it's always been the case that you didn't just regurgitate the facts in an exam, but used them to answer specific questions to show you could evaluate and interpret.
As for the Wikipedia thing, Kolley, I took that from a Government proposal. If the Govt say twittering etc is going to be on the syllabus, it will be. Will teachers have any more choice over that than they did with SATS, which the majority of teachers also disagreed with?
SATS were/are a disgrace for reasons which have been given often enough. Compare, say, French teching under SATS with the old methods. My daughter wasn't taught grammar and vocabulary at all in the way I was, she was merely given lists of phrases to learn. The result is she can't have a conversation in French. I can, though I haven't studied the language for 40 years.