IN DEFENCE OF THE PRESS
By Steve Dawson - 28/08/2008 22:11
http://hartlepoolunited.rivals.net/News/pgArticle.aspx?artid=13654_4062486THE recent news that HUFC have banned both the Hartlepool Mail and the Northern Echo has all the makings of a serious own goal by the club.
Both papers have recently run articles confirming that they have been banned for the foreseeable future and this can only hurt the club in my humble opinion.
It appears that the original dispute has something to do with commercial image rights as the club has been banned from taking photos at home games and was very upset when the local paper was supplied with images from the Northern Echo. I am sure that everyone has noticed that the copyright notice on the bottom of all articles on the official web site seems to be much larger than of late.
Of course, this is nothing new in the history of the club. Speaking as an ex-Mail employee I can remember numerous conflicts involving Arthur Pickering, Jeff Stelling, Colin Cameron and James Bond on the Mail side, and Vince Barker, John Smart and Garry Gibson on the Pools side.
Invariably, the disputes would be petty and would be as a result of a perceived criticism of players, managers, owners or even just a misinterpretation of a match report, and which would involve a two-week ban, petulance on both sides which was then forgotten in a month.
But this seems to be far more serious.
The board of Hartlepool United need to finally understand the uniqueness of owning a football club. It is not as if IOR bought a manufacturing division where profit, turnover and capabilities can be quantified on a spreadsheet - it simply is a football club.
A football club that causes countless discussions and arguments in pubs and clubs, a football club where supporters have spent tens of thousands of pounds over decades to grotty dim ends of the country to watch their team in an uncovered stand in torrential rain on a cold January Tuesday night. A club that inspires devotion and passion and faith and belief. To some supporters HUFC is their church - when did that last happen in a manufacturing plant!! This is a principle the owners refuse to accept.
I suspect what really sticks in the throat of the board, is the fact that they cannot do without the supporters - it is their money that ultimately pays the bills, and to be beholding to this group I suspect sticks in their collective throats.
This is where the press can help the club, with its daily stories (not the sanitised Politburo versions on the official web site), its comments, rumours and match previews, when it is done right and generates interest, a well written preview can add hundreds to the gate of a home game.
Down the years, it has been standard practice by clubs around the country to leak interest of a player to the press, therefore getting it to write an article that suddenly makes the intended player aware of the interest and therefore making the negotiation far easier. It was a comfortable association that benefitted both parties.
But the naivety of owning a football club is long gone, gone forever are the genial chairmen and now all clubs are run in an extremely hard nosed manner where multiple revenue streams are paramount.
I would hope that this current spat would be a storm in a teacup and in a normal environment would be resolved with an off the record chat over lunch and a nice bottle of wine. But the current (non football) management team have consistently shown their contempt for supporters and press alike and I suspect something major will have to give before this current dispute is resolved.
Ken just never learns does he.