chip fireball wrote:
tickhill, your conclusion is that we accept either the opinion of tax paying poolie or " liverpool football club. "
however the original question asked would you sign him if, hypothetically, you were the manager, and, hypothetically, you had the choice.
on the evidence of his own eyes tax has suggested it would be a waste of time signing him.
you then sarcastically ridicule him on the basis that at some point over 12 months ago liverpool felt he had some potential.
are you seriously suggesting that at this point he is a better player than nelson collins or clark ?
if not then are you suggesting we sign a 19 year old centre half as 4th choice behind those 3 even though he has shown himself to be a liability this season?
and that on the basis that liverpool think he has potential even though for all we know they may no longer think that?
if you are not prepared to answer the question then why knock folk with the bollocks to answer it?
we have greater needs in other positions.
imho.
Chip, If you are asking if I would sign him then the answer is no I wouldn't.
If you are asking whether I would take the opinion of LFC over a message board punter then the answer is LFC. I am not questioning the right of TPP to have an opinion on Antwi, but his 'hallucinating' comment suggested that others who might want Antwi to come were making him hallucinate. He was ridiculing other people's comments by that remark.
Your next comment doesn't apply to me as I have never suggested that we sign Antwi. Therefore it is obvious that I don't prefer him to Clark, Nelson or Collins.
There is no evidence that I have suggested we sign Antwi as any choice.
I don't know Liverpool's current opinion on Antwi so I can't answer the last bit.
So, to sum up.
1.I have never suggested Antwi would be a success.
2.I have never suggested that we should sign him.
3.I have never suggested he should be fourth choice.
4.I have never suggested he was better than Collins, Clark or Nelson.
But.
5.I have suggested that he has potential and a raw talent.
6.I have stated that if there is a choice between the opinion of LFC and a message board punter, then I prefer the opinion of LFC.
The only point you have a quarrel with is Point 6 , the rest you have made up to try and bolster your argument.
The other day MR I stated in his address to us all that sarcasm was acceptable. TPP was being sarcastic with his 'hallucination' and I returned the compliment. In my post, as a contribution to this thread, I gave straightforward observations. If you don't agree with those observations then that is your right. What is not your right, however, is to add things in which I have not said.
I meant no offence to TPP and I'm sure he meant none with his comments. You, on the other hand, decided to have a go. By all means have a go whenever you like, but try to do it a bit more factually.